What the law actually asks for
The Companies Act and the CSR Rules require a company covered by Section 135 to include an annual report on CSR in its Board’s report, in a format set by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA). The format is a set of tables. It asks for the CSR policy in outline, the committee, the obligation, the amount spent, what stayed unspent and the assets created. Project details go into a separate filing, Form CSR-2. Neither asks how many people a project reached. Only the largest spenders must add impact assessments: companies with an average CSR obligation of ₹10 crore or more, for projects of ₹1 crore or more. For everyone else, the format does not ask whether the programme worked.
Most companies treat the CSR annual report as a compliance annex and nothing more. They fill the tables. A director or the chief executive signs, with the chairman of the CSR Committee. They file CSR-2. The job is done. And the result is a document that nobody — not the communities served, not the CSR Committee, not the employees who volunteered, not the investors reading ESG disclosures — finds useful.
The compliance-vs-communication gap
The gap is not between intention and execution. Most CSR teams are doing genuine, thoughtful work in the field. The gap is between what happened and what got written down. The programmes generate data: beneficiary surveys, baseline and end-line assessments, field photos, NGO partner reports, volunteer logs. That data sits in folders. The annual report gets the summary table.
A company can spend crores on CSR and almost nothing on capturing and communicating what that money actually did. The CSR annual report becomes a record of spend, not a record of impact. A compliant document that nobody wants to read.
What a good CSR annual report does
A CSR annual report that works serves three audiences simultaneously. The regulator gets complete MCA disclosures in the prescribed format, consistent with Form CSR-2 — the format is unchanged. The CSR Committee and board get a clear view of what the portfolio is doing, what the outcome evidence says, and where the gaps are — the kind of document that actually informs next year’s budget decision. And the external audience — employees, communities, media, investors reading BRSR Principle 8 — gets a story that is specific, honest, and worth reading.
The mechanics are not complicated. An outcome statement instead of an output count. A programme logic (theory of change) in plain language. One case study per major programme. A candid “what we learned” paragraph. The MCA-mandated table stays; it is just surrounded by context that makes it meaningful.
The data is usually there
The most common objection is that the data does not exist: no baselines, no end-line surveys, no documentation from the implementing NGO. This is sometimes true, but less often than assumed. NGO partners file reports. Impact assessments are commissioned (the CSR Rules require them of the largest spenders). Volunteer coordinators track hours and feedback. The problem is not missing data — it is unsynthesised data. Someone needs to pull it together, structure it against a simple results framework, and write it up. That is the work.
When the data genuinely does not exist — no baseline, no outcome measurement, no partner reporting worth using — that is itself a useful finding. A CSR annual report that says “we have no credible outcome evidence for this programme and here is how we will fix that next year” is more trustworthy, and more useful to the CSR Committee, than one that invents a beneficiary count.
The BRSR Principle 8 connection
Since FY 2022–23, the top 1,000 listed companies must file a BRSR (Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report). Its Principle 8, on inclusive growth and equitable development, takes CSR data in two leadership indicators, both voluntary: the amount spent on CSR projects in aspirational districts, and the number of people who benefitted from each CSR project, with the share from vulnerable and marginalised groups.
The CSR annual report does not ask for a beneficiary count; the BRSR does. A company that keeps beneficiary records for each project, with the evidence behind each count, can answer both from the same data. A company that rebuilds the counts at year end cannot defend them. The two documents should be the same work, not two separate compliance exercises.
What to change, and when
The single highest-leverage intervention is to require outcome evidence as part of the NGO partner agreement — not a separate ask at reporting time. If the partner contract specifies mid-line and end-line assessment responsibilities, outcome data arrives at reporting time rather than being chased. Everything else — report structure, writing quality, BRSR alignment — flows from that one upstream decision.
The window to change is the current year’s CSR committee planning cycle, not the reporting cycle. If you are reading this before April, you can redesign the partner engagement for the coming financial year. If you are reading this in Q3, the best you can do is collect what evidence exists and set up properly for the next financial year. Either way, the sooner the CSR committee decides it wants a useful document rather than a compliant one, the sooner it gets one.
Where Alt fits
Alt prepares reporting inputs for the CSR committee, the board’s report and BRSR Principle 8, from an end-of-period review in which each result has its evidence graded. Each engagement is scoped with you.
See Rupee to Result ↦See our CSR work ↦Book a call ↦
Sources, checked 20 November 2026: Companies Act, 2013, sections 134(3)(o) and 135; Companies (Corporate Social Responsibility Policy) Rules, 2014, rule 8 and Annexure II (as substituted on 20 September 2022); Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, rule 12(1B) and Form CSR-2; SEBI Master Circular for listed entities (updated 30 January 2026), Annexure 16, Principle 8.